Yesterday I received my Advance Reader’s Copy (ARC) of What Light, by Jay Asher. I loved Thirteen Reason’s Why – and both the content and the form of that novel have really stayed with me. It is a novel that has often been on hold in my library, and students have fallen in love with it year after year, often hearing about it through word of mouth.
What Light, by Jay Asher, is another way for him to explore the ideas of redemption and forgiveness (he says as much in his opening letter to the ARC), but with a much happier construct. Sierra, the main character in the story, runs a tree farm in Oregon with her parents, and every year they go down to California between Thanksgiving and Christmas to run a tree lot. Sierra misses her friends from Oregon, and also loves her time in California, with her best friend there, Heather. The majority of the novel takes place in California – and this might be their last year on the lot there. They will keep the farm, but the actual business at the lot has been in decline. Sierra is notoriously picky with her romances, but then one day Caleb catches her eye.
Despite being warned about a terrifying incident in Caleb’s past, Sierra and Caleb start a tentative relationship – one that looks destined for heartbreak. Will Sierra get a Christmas miracle? What actually happened in Caleb’s past? Should everyone be judged by their worst day? These are some of the questions that the novel posits, and the plot does have a nice quick pace to it.
I have been eagerly waiting for my copy, ever since I stumbled across the first Teen Book Festival Event at Barnes and Nobel and won the trivia contest. I felt guilty and gave half of my swag away, but as a school librarian, I am excited to have access to Advance Reader’s copies this year, both to read and assess for collection development, and to share with students. I am planning to have students turn in book recommendations this year, and do a drawing each month with the students that participate. I will give away various prizes, but I am sure the ARC’s will go first.
I did enjoy What Light, although I do think that some additional character development would bolster the story. Throughout the novel, Sierra is always making coffee with hot chocolate and a peppermint stick, and this novel is the equivalent of that. Lots of good feeling, warmth and nostalgia, with the hint of something darker underneath. While I do have some hesitations about this novel, I think it will prove popular with a lot of my high school students, and I also really like the hopeful message of the story. With so many dystopian novels crowding the scene, I have admitted that there are times I would like more “books about puppies” – and this book fits that desire quite nicely. While not my favorite by this author, I still finished it pretty quickly, and fell easily into the rhythms of the story. This will make a good addition, also, as a holiday story – of which there are really not many for the secondary level.
Finally, I am always glad when there is a novel that presents people who are farmers, or live in a more rural area, as regular people – not people defined fully by their geography as backwards, or stupid. As a teacher/librarian in a rural district, I can say that simply putting teenagers in a rural setting does not change their desire to be the best person they can be, or their need to go through the turmoil of adolescence and find their own ways in life.